St. George Stock (modern guide) · 1850–1922
A Guide to Stoicism 4 ¶26 — St. George Stock (modern guide)
From “Ethic”
Original English text (1908)
St. George Stock (modern guide), A Guide to Stoicism 4 ¶26
By things indifferent were meant such as did not necessarily contribute to virtue, for instance health, wealth, strength, and honor. It is possible to have all these and not be virtuous, it is possible also to be virtuous without them. But we have now to learn that though these things are neither good nor evil, and are therefore not matter for choice or avoidance, they are far from being indifferent in the sense of arousing neither impulse nor repulsion. There are things indeed that are indifferent in the latter sense, such as whether you put out your finger this way or that, whether you stoop to pick up a straw or not, whether the number of hairs on your head be odd or even. But things of this sort are exceptional. The bulk of things other than virtue and vice do arouse in us either impulse or repulsion. Let it be understood then that there are two senses of the word indifferent-- (1) neither good nor bad (2) neither awaking impulse nor repulsion
Cite this passage
St. George Stock (modern guide), A Guide to Stoicism 4 ¶26 (1908)
https://whatwouldstoicsdo.com/passage/a-guide-to-stoicism/4.26
St. George Stock, Stoicism (1908), text of the Haldeman-Julius reprint “A Guide to Stoicism”. Text: Project Gutenberg #7514. Sources and licences
In plain English
AI-written notesHealth, wealth, strength and honour are neither good nor evil because you can have them without being virtuous or be virtuous without them. Even so, most such things still draw us toward or away from them, so indifferent has two senses: not good or bad, and not provoking any pull at all.
Older wording
- “indifferent”
- — neither good nor bad in itself
- “impulse”
- — a pull toward something
- “repulsion”
- — a pull away from something
Themes and situations
- Virtue and character
- Wealth and poverty
- Illness and the body
- Desire and craving
- Money, status and wanting more
- Losing money
- Illness or diagnosis
Quote cards
The opening line of this passage as an image, with its citation — for sharing or keeping.